Mar 20, 2025

The Hidden Risk in Value-Based Care: Outdated Healthcare Data Management

The promise of value-based care (VBC) is clear: better outcomes, improved member satisfaction, and lower costs. But for many payers, achieving these goals remains elusive — not because of a lack of strategy or intent, but because of a persistent, preventable problem: bad data.

At the heart of VBC is coordination. Payers must work seamlessly with providers, members, and third-party solutions to deliver timely, high-quality care. But when core datasets like provider directories are inaccurate or out of sync, the entire system falters. In short, healthcare data management isn’t just a backend IT concern — it’s a foundational element of care delivery, and it’s failing under the current status quo.

The Real-World Impact of Inaccurate Data

Last year, researchers found that 80% of entries in provider directories of the nation’s five largest health plans were inaccurate. That means millions of members are using faulty information to choose care providers — leading to delays in treatment, surprise medical bills, and eroded trust.

This data dysfunction ripples across the entire payer ecosystem:

  • Member experience suffers when patients are sent to the wrong provider or denied care because of out-of-network discrepancies.
  • Administrative costs skyrocket as internal teams chase down provider updates manually, reconcile inaccurate claims, or rework denials.
  • Care quality deteriorates when physicians are misclassified, specialists are mismatched, or chronic conditions are managed without the full clinical picture.

For payers operating under value-based contracts, these issues don’t just increase cost — they compromise performance on quality metrics, reimbursement rates, and member retention.

Why Healthcare Data Management Is a Strategic Priority

Despite operating in one of the most data-rich industries, healthcare remains held back by disconnected systems and outdated workflows. Manual roster updates, siloed eligibility systems, and point-to-point integrations are still common — even as payers are being asked to deliver more personalized, high-touch care.

Effective healthcare data management is about much more than just maintaining directories. It enables payers to:

  • Standardize and synchronize data across all sources — including eligibility, provider, and clinical systems
  • Support compliance with regulations like the No Surprises Act by ensuring accurate, up-to-date provider information
  • Power real-time decision-making with accessible, clean, structured data that can drive everything from utilization management to care gap closure
  • Reduce administrative burden by eliminating repetitive manual data entry and file matching
  • Improve claims accuracy and reduce denials by ensuring clean data flows between all systems and partners

Inaccurate data doesn’t just create inefficiencies — it creates risk. In an industry shifting toward accountability for outcomes, payers simply can’t afford bad data any longer.

The Link Between Clean Data and Better Outcomes

Healthcare data management plays a critical role in enabling proactive care, especially for populations with complex or chronic conditions. Without reliable provider information and integrated data systems, members may fall through the cracks in the care continuum.

Poor provider matching leads to missed appointments, delayed treatment, and member churn. It also drives up emergency care utilization and downstream costs — directly undermining the goals of value-based models. For members managing conditions like diabetes or chronic kidney disease, the impact of these lapses is not just financial — it’s life-altering.

Related: Unlocking Value-Based Care: Why Healthcare Interoperability is the Missing Link

How Modern Infrastructure Solves for the VBC Data Dilemma

The good news is that payers don’t need to rip and replace their entire tech stack to fix the data problem. What they need is a more intelligent, flexible layer that sits across existing systems and creates a single source of truth.

Modern healthcare data management platforms offer:

  • Real-time data ingestion and transformation from APIs, flat files, and legacy sources
  • Automation of provider roster updates, reducing manual lift and ensuring accuracy across systems
  • Seamless integration with claims, utilization, and care management platforms
  • Observability and monitoring that alerts teams when something breaks or goes out of sync — before it impacts members

This enables payers to act on data, not chase it.

From Liability to Leverage: Turning Data Into an Asset

For payers, fixing healthcare data management isn’t just about reducing operational pain — it’s about enabling long-term success under value-based care.

Accurate, real-time data allows payers to:

  • Launch new products or carve-outs with confidence
  • Improve alignment with providers and third-party vendors
  • Reduce member abrasion and avoid revenue leakage
  • Power analytics and AI to forecast risk and improve outcomes

In other words, good data is no longer a “nice to have” — it’s the foundation of competitive advantage.

Make Your Data Work for You

Flume Health helps payers simplify their healthcare data management strategy through flexible, format-agnostic data integration. Whether you're trying to clean up provider rosters, launch a new plan product, or unlock real-time decision-making, Flume’s platform delivers the infrastructure to make your data work the way it should — accurately, efficiently, and at scale.

If your VBC goals are being held back by outdated data systems, let’s change that.

Reach out today to learn how we can help.

Schedule a Demo

Fill out the form with your details and a team member will get in touch shortly